A short while ago, I answered a question on Quora about why misogyny is on the rise. My answer got away from me; this is an elaboration and expansion on that answer.
Thoughts part 0

Image: HayDmitri
Yes, misogyny is on the rise. The last decade has seen a tsunami of online toxic hate, with an astonishing number of women experiencing harassment on a regular basis. The “manosphere,” the culture of male influencers and organized misogyny, has gone through the ever-loving roof, as extensively documented in peer-reviewed research.
But why?
Buckle up, long essay is loooong.
Thoughts Part 1: The World has Changed

Dating used to be so very different. Just in my lifetime, the nature and foundation of romantic relationships have changed. In my lifetime, banks could refuse to allow women to have a bank account without a male co-signer. In my lifetime, women could be refused from juries, or could be refused a mortgage unless a man was also on the mortgage. In my lifetime, men assumed control of women’s property, money, and possessions upon marriage. (Head and Master laws weren’t repealed nationwide until 1979!)
It once was that the single most important criterion a man could have was financial stability. Without it, women struggled and could easily end up destitute. That meant if you were a man with a decent job and money, you were guaranteed to find a woman.
Didn’t matter if you were an asshole. Didn’t matter if you smelled like potato salad that had been left all day in the sun. Didn’t matter if you were a violent drunk. Didn’t matter if you had no personality. Didn’t matter if you were as interesting and engaging as a road-killed possum. If you had money, you had a wife. That was the deal.
Nowadays, women have their own careers, their own money, their own businesses, their own financial security. If you’re a douchebag with a job, that’s not good enough anymore.
But a lot of men didn’t get the memo. They wake up one day and realize they have money and a job…
…and yet, women don’t want to talk to them.
That wasn’t the deal! That wasn’t what they were promised!
It’s actually easier now to find female companionship than it was before. You just need to be interesting. But that’s a bar a lot of men can’t seem to reach.
Ironically, a lot of those disenfranchised men have turned to bizarre stories about how you have to be 6 feet tall with 6-pack abs and a 6-figure income to attract a woman, because blah blah blah hypergamy blah blah blah, even though that is literally less true now than at any other time in all of recorded history, because…
Thoughts Part 2: There is a ton of money in lying to lonely men

Image: llcv, licensed from Depositphotos
A lot of men didn’t get the memo: it’s no longer enough to have a job. If you’re an asshole, women won’t dig that. Into that space moved a very particular and specific breed of predator: the male influencer.
These people made bank by telling disaffected, lonely men, “Women are evil. You you should be really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really angry at all these bitches and harpies who are denying you the sex and companionship you deserve. Now buy my $1,000 program.”
A while back, my wife, my crush, and I spent months reading pickup artist books and men’s rights pages and so on, for a podcast we ultimately didn’t record because holy fuck. (That experience drained away our will to keep podcasting, in fact.)
But here’s the thing about these meninists:
They only make money from disaffected men who can’t get laid. Men who find a happy, healthy relationship drop out of their audience. They stop buying the programs and stop subscribing to the YouTube channels.
That means, and it is very, very important to understand this if you want to understand a big chunk of 2020s culture, that means these meninists have to give advice that will guarantee their audience can’t get laid.
That’s why so much meninist advice is so bizarre. Like “pheromone maxxing,” which is literally men advising other men “don’t bathe before a date, don’t use deodorant, don’t shower before you go out, because it increases the magnetic power of your body’s natural pheromones.”
When the Tate brothers were arrested, they literally testified in court, under oath, that their online personas are just an act, they aren’t real, the advice they give isn’t real, they’re just pretending and role-playing.
These men are predators. They’re predators against women, yes; as I write this, they’re awaiting extradition from the US, with two different countries waiting to put them on trial on charges of rape and human trafficking.
But the thing men don’t get is that even more than being predators of women, they are predators of men. They deliberately, knowingly, intentionally give men advice that they know will prevent those men from ever getting laid, for the purpose of keeping those men lonely and alienated and angry, because they make money doing it.
They prey on men whose social skills are so poor, those men don’t even realize they’re being manipulated and used. And guess what? It’s not women who are doing it!
There’s an entire multibillion-dollar industry that relies on keeping men angry, lonely, and glued to their screens to generate revenue. “Redpill” content online, aided by social media algorithms that prioritize content that generates rage and hate, is funded by companies that generate revenue from the fury of disaffected men. Online misogyny is an industry, and the men being preyed on don’t even understand that they’re being manipulated.
Speaking of money from misogyny…
Thoughts Part 3: Men are from Earth, women are from Earth

Image: NASA
It’s not enough to have money anymore. That’s left a lot of men saying “okay, what do women want, then?”
Which is absolutely positively 100% the wrong question to ask.
There is no such thing as what women want. There is no such thing as how women think or what women feel.
Men are not from Mars. Women are not from Venus. Men and women aren’t separate, alien things. You don’t have to figure out women. You cannot “understand women;” in fact, trying to “understand women” is sexism, because you are starting from the assumption that all women are basically the same.
Every woman you will ever meet is different and wants different things. This is obvious when you understand that women are people.
“I don’t know how to talk to women!”
Do you have male friends? Do you know how to talk to men? Then congratulations, you know how to talk to women. Just do that! Men are people. If you can talk to men, you can talk to people. If you can talk to people, you can talk to women.
People say they “don’t understand women” because they meet Sally, and Sally says “I like when guys buy me flowers.” So they’re all like “women want flowers.” Then they start dating Lisa, and they buy Lisa flowers, and Lisa is like “what am I supposed to do with these? I would rather we spend time together.” So they’re like “women don’t want flowers, women want attention.” So they meet Carol, and Carol says “we spend too much time together, you’re smothering me,” and these men are like “AAAAH I DON’T UNDERSTAND WOMEN THEY’RE SO CONFUSING!!!11!1!!oneone”
No, dude, grow up. This is fucking simple. If Sally tells you she wants flowers, that doesn’t mean women want flowers, that means Sally wants flowers. If Lisa tells you she wants attention, that doesn’t mean women want attention, that means Lisa wants attention.
Say it with me: Different women want different things. Understanding what Sally wants does not tell you what women want.
These men are operating on a system from the past: Women want money. The way you get a woman is to have money. But now, if women don’t want money, what do they want? They try to figure out the new contract, and struggle to understand that there is no new contract. You find a woman by being someone she wants to spend time with. Different women want different things.
This inability to understand that gives rise to…
Thoughts part 4: Incel culture and the rise of anger as a personality

The dude in this photo is mass murderer Elliot Rodger. He murdered 6 people and shot 14 others because he couldn’t get a date. He is revered in some circles, where he’s called “Saint Elliot.” Other mass murderers have talked about “doing an Elliot” before going on murder sprees.

This is actual, serious, unironic iconography from an incel site. People literally, not figuratively, literally worship him.
The term “incel” was made up by a woman who had trouble dating and wanted a community of other people who shared her difficulties to talk to. It turned into an ugly cult of self-loathing, hate, and violence.
At first, people who called themselves “incels” would talk on internet forums about ways to boost their self-esteem and how to dress better and so on. But there’s a peculiar thing about social media. Multiple peer-reviewed, independent studies have demonstrated that the best way to get engagement on social media is rage and hate. Rage and hate are the currency of every social platform. When you apply that idea to a group of people who share in common the fact that they are lonely, and can’t find companionship, well…
Predictably, incel communities started directing their loneliness and frustration outward, at women. They developed their own jargon, using words like “femoid,” “foid,” and “toilet” to talk about women.
Right now, as I type this, the most active thread on the incels dot is forum is titled “Women did this to us. With revenge in mind women reduced us to level of insects. They WILL pay for what they’ve done with punishments worse than death”
The first post in the thread reads:
Women are jew-like parasites who hate hard manual labor above all else. Therefore, I suggest that we subject them to the most backbreaking, most psychologically devastating, and physically hazardous labor imaginable. Make them toil day and night in mines and oil rigs. Make them clean the dirtiest and shittiest of toilets. And most importantly, make them work and live in a way which erodes their physical beauty, sexuality, and softness little by little everyday while depriving them of nutrition, sleep, and comfort because this is the source of their power and goddesshood.Any woman who refuses to obey should be dragged down into the darkest of torture chambers and subjected to the worst medieval torture that makes everyday backbreaking labor feel like heaven!
Then they wonder why women won’t date them, and tell themselves it’s because of their “bone structure” and their “facial shape” and they can’t do anything about it because it’s completely out of their hands.
They make rage and hate the whole of their personality, the defining and overriding trait in their psychological makeup. They form communities where they marinate in this toxic stew, then they persuade themselves that their loneliness is somebody else’s fault. They blame women for everything wrong in their lives. Anyone who disagrees is branded a “fakecel” and banned from the community.
Unsurprisingly, these sites are entry points to the alt-right. It’s not just women they hate. They hate Jews, they hate Black people, they hate Asians, they hate Hispanics.
(Before you ask, yes, I do read incel forums. I’m a long-time lurker on incels dot is, for the same reason I read Dominionist Christian forums and the Nazi Stormfront site: because these people are dangerous and it’s wise to understand what they’re doing.)
Thoughts part 5: Everything old is new again

The Rape of the Sabines by Domingo Álvarez Enciso / After Pietro da Cortona, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Redirect/page/76612046
It’s easy to think about this new wave of misogyny in terms of a pendulum of attitudes toward women swinging back and forth. Reality is more complicated. It’s not a pendulum; what actually happens is that social attitudes act like a strange attractor in mathematics, a chaotic and complicated orbit around two or more points.

Image: Wikimol, Dschwen – Own work based on: images Lorenz system r28 s10 b2-6666.png by Wikimol and Lorenz attractor.svg by Dschwen, Wikimedia Commons
Unitarian minister Theodore Parker, repeated by Dr. Martin Luther King, said the moral arc of the universe is long, but it bends toward justice. It would be nice if that were true.
Problem is, for every shift in social perception, there are winners and losers.
The primitive, simplistic interpretation of feminism is “women want to put themselves in charge and make men subordinate.” The people who say this live in a world where men are supreme and women are inferior, but they are cognitively incapable of comprehending an egalitarian world. When they hear that women are not inferior, they can only imagine that must mean women want to be superior, a phenomenon sociologists call “flipped hierarchies.”
These people struggle to understanding the idea that nobody is superior. There are studies on this. Just as a person on the lower tiers of Kohlberg’s stages of moral development are incapable of comprehending the higher stages, a person trapped in a hierarchical mindset cannot comprehend a non-hierarchical world. Somebody has to be on top, and if that’s not men it only leaves women, obviously.
This isn’t true, but it doesn’t change the fact that feminism has created winners and losers.
The winners are women, obviously, but also men who don’t have stereotypical ideas about relationships and men who don’t live conventional lives.
The losers are the men who have nothing to offer besides money.
The fact that feminism also helps men by dismantling ideas about what a man “has to be” or getting rid of ideas that harm men like men aren’t allowed to show emotion doesn’t matter. These men believe they were offered a bargain: get a good job and you’ll receive a wife. Now that hasn’t happened and they feel betrayed. Feminism is a big part of this; women who are financially stable on their own don’t need support from a man.
So the world has changed, and that’s created losers, and those losers are pushing back by trying to rewind the clock to an era where men were in charge and women depended on men.
That pushback manifests in thousands of ways. Politics (the rise of populism is a multi-headed hydra, but one of those heads is unquestionably alientated men), economics, religion (religiosity in the US is plummeting, but patriarchal Evangelical Cristian denominations are growing), you name it.
The rise of Donald Trump has made overt, in-your-face, public misogyny acceptable. The Strange Attractor is pulling back toward “yeah, women suck and how do you like THEM apples?” The drivers for that are the same as the drivers for incel communities and meninists: There are a lot of odious men in the world.
These men, men who have nothing to offer except money, men who are generally disagreeable and unpleasant to be around, have unquestionably lost under feminism, and it’s disingenuous to say otherwise. They’re lonely, they’re alienated, and they don’t want to hear that maybe if they were less odious they wouldn’t struggle so much.
In people like Donald Trump, they see someone who acts the way they wish they could act. They want to turn the clock back to a time when women had no choice but to suffer with an odious man because it was the only way she wouldn’t starve.






























